What an expense ratio is
Every mutual fund and ETF costs money to run. Someone has to pick the investments, keep the records and send out reports, and the fund passes those costs on to its investors. The expense ratio is that cost for a year, shown as a percentage of the fund’s average net assets. Investor.gov, the SEC’s investor education site, lists what it can include: management fees, distribution and service (12b-1) fees, and other expenses such as legal and accounting costs.
You never pay it as a bill. The fund pays its expenses out of fund assets, which lowers the value of everyone’s shares. So the fee is easy to miss: it shows up only as a balance that’s a little smaller than it would otherwise be.
Why small fees add up
A 1% fee sounds tiny, but it’s charged every year on your whole balance, including all the growth you’ve built up. As your balance grows, so does the fee. And the money the fund takes can’t grow for you anymore, so a fee costs you what you pay plus what that money would have earned.
The SEC shows this with a simple example. $100,000 that grows 4% a year for 20 years is worth about $208,000 with a 0.25% yearly fee, about $198,000 with a 0.50% fee, and about $179,000 with a 1% fee. The fee difference of three quarters of a percentage point costs almost $30,000. The SEC’s bulletin puts it this way: a fund with higher costs must perform better than a lower-cost fund to give you the same returns.
How the calculator works
You enter one investment (a starting amount, monthly contributions, a yearly return and a number of years) and two expense ratios. The calculator runs the same money through both funds. The only difference between them is the fee.
The return is added a little each day, so that with no fee your money grows by exactly the yearly return you entered. The fee is worked out daily too: each day the fund takes 1/365 of its expense ratio on your balance. Over a year, that comes to about the expense ratio times your average balance. For a single investment, these results match FINRA’s Fund Analyzer to the cent. That’s the tool the SEC’s investor bulletins suggest for comparing fund fees.
The calculator then shows three numbers for the higher-fee fund:
- Extra fees paid: how much more that fund takes in fees than the cheaper one.
- Growth those fees lost: what the extra fees would have earned if they’d stayed invested.
- What the higher fee costs you: the two added together, which is exactly the gap between the two funds’ final balances.
Worked example
Say you invest $10,000 now and $200 a month for 30 years, and the investments earn 6% a year before fees. You compare Fund A, with an expense ratio of 0.05%, and Fund B, at 1%. Either way you put in $82,000.
- Fund A grows to $249,630 and takes $1,451 in fees over the 30 years.
- Fund B grows to $204,064 and takes $25,288 in fees. In the first year its fee is $114; in the last year it’s $1,979, because by then the balance is much bigger.
- Fund B ends with $45,566 less. That’s $23,837 of extra fees, plus $21,728 of growth that money would have earned if it had stayed invested.
The two expense ratios are only 0.95 percentage points apart, yet over 30 years the higher one costs you about 56% of everything you put in.
Finding and comparing fees
- Read the fee table. Every mutual fund and ETF prospectus has a standardized table of fees and expenses. The expense ratio is the line called “Total annual fund operating expenses”. Fund expenses also appear in the shareholder reports funds send twice a year.
- Compare funds side by side. FINRA’s free Fund Analyzer covers more than 30,000 mutual funds, ETFs, exchange-traded notes and money market funds. Look up a fund’s expense ratio there, then enter it here.
- Check the share class. Many mutual funds sell several share classes that hold the same investments but charge different fees, so the same fund can cost you more or less depending on the class you buy.
- Look beyond the expense ratio. Some funds charge sales loads or redemption fees, and you may pay brokerage commissions or an adviser’s fee as well. The costs a fund pays to buy and sell its own investments aren’t in the expense ratio either.
- Fees aren’t the only thing that matters. The SEC notes that choosing a fund involves more than picking the one with the lowest fees. Check what the fund invests in and whether its risks suit your goals.
To see how regular investing adds up over time, try our compound interest calculator or the index investing calculator, which uses real market history.